After four-plus years of almost-daily blog reading, I can confidently say this: Seth Godin continues to be my single most thought-provoking blogger (with Grant McCracken a close second).
Today, Seth comments on Radiohead's recent announcement that it would release its next CD on the 'net on a pay-what-you-want basis. Seth then asks why it is that Radiohead was preceded by Prince and Madonna in using this new approach to music pricing. His answer is right on:
Most industries innovate from both ends:
- The outsiders go first because they have nothing to lose.
- The winners go next because they can afford to and they want to stay winners.
- It's the mediocre middle that sits and waits and watches.
Sharp insight. Of course the outsiders go first, as they are storming the walls of the citadel. The winners going next, however, is a bit counterintuitive, as, unlike outsiders, they have the most to lose. But, being winners, they have the resources to back up their guts.
Then we have the mediocre middle. Most business treatises denigrate the mediocre middle. It is the least sexy of all market positions and approaches. No striving, no disquiet; only watchful waiting.
The middle's mantra: When the market settles down and speaks, loudly and unambiguously, follow it.
This can be a highly seductive approach. After all, in these turbulent times, how many market innovators quickly surface and just as quickly disappear from view? Better to sit and wait while others sort out the risks, right? Think of the hundreds of businesses that live in that zone.
Seth's final word on this phenomenon is illustrative:
So, in every industry, the middle waits. And watches. And then, once
they realize they can survive the switch (or once they're persuaded
that their current model is truly fading away), they jump in.
The irony, of course, is that by jumping in last, they're condemning themselves to more mediocrity.
This, of course, is the voice of the innovator, looking at the mediocre middle-player as a lesser life form; a loser.
But, the fact is that many, many businesses love their mediocrity. It is their badge of honor; their central source of comfort. Living within the herd reduces the risk of being eaten by the predators, after all.
Once, while consulting with a firm that fit this description, I was pushing for an innovative approach. The client, an exasperated executive, said to me: "hey, that's what everybody in this industry does; so it can't be so bad."
To which I replied, "there's a great theme for an ad campaign: buy from us, we're no worse than the other guys!"
Years later, I see that this was exactly what this company was aiming for: the comfortably mediocre middle.
Recent Comments